Can you imagine raising up leaders who will take inexperienced people up to the highest summit on earth?
It’s not without its rigor.
One Sherpa guide's bio is typical: starting as a porter/kitchen boy, he worked his way up to assistant guide within 3 years, gaining his full guide license in 2007. Carrying loads is a job many young Sherpas do before graduating to become a guide. The first test is simple:
Can you be trusted with loads before you're trusted with people?
The application for connection ministry is obvious. But, raising up new leaders starts with identifying them… and unfortunately, we have stuck to asking the same subconscious familiar question: “who’s already a leader?”
We need to ask two different questions:
How can I identify a potential leader we haven’t noticed or activated yet?
How can people who gravitate toward leadership self-identify?
For now, we will answer Question 1 — and I'll stick to 12 signals that don't usually show up in response to this question...
1. Watch who other people follow without being asked.
In any group, find the person whose opinion others check before deciding. In a small group, watch who people glance at after someone says something awkward. That kind of influence comes before any title.
2. Notice who fixes things nobody assigned them.
Someone restocks the connection card table, or texts the newcomer they met last week, or quietly sets up a system so the coffee doesn't run out. People who take ownership without being given authority are showing you how they'd lead.
3. Look at how they handle being overlooked.
Find someone who served faithfully and got passed over, or whose idea got shot down, and see what happened next. Did they sulk, gossip, or keep showing up and even constructively say something about it? Character shows most clearly when nobody is watching and nobody is thanking them.
4. Pay attention to the questions they ask.
Most volunteers ask "What do you need me to do?" Potential leaders also ask "Why do we do it this way?" or "What happens to people after they fill out the card?" They're thinking about the system and the people the system is meant to serve, not just their task.
5. Ask the people who don't get asked.
Parking lot volunteers, nursery workers, and the setup and teardown crews see everyone's unguarded moments. Asking them "Who's someone here you'd follow?" can turn up names that staff has never heard.
6. Notice who brings people with them.
If someone keeps showing up with a coworker, a neighbor, or the new couple from their street, they're already doing relational recruiting, which is most of volunteer leadership.
7. Treat appropriate pushback as a good sign.
Someone who respectfully disagrees with you in private, and then supports the decision in public, is showing exactly the maturity you want. Agreeable people aren't always leadership material. Loyal dissenters who care more about results than artificial harmony often are.
8. Look at their vocational life.
The quiet guy in row 12 might manage forty people at a large company. A lot of churches only measure people by their church resumé, and they miss leaders who were never invited to lead anything there.
9. Test with small, real responsibility.
Hand someone a contained job with actual stakes, like "Can you own follow-up for this month's newcomers?" Then watch whether they close the loop, ask for help well, and report back without being chased. A trial assignment like that tells you more than any interview.
10. Watch how they treat the person who can't do anything for them.
That might be the socially awkward newcomer, the kid, or the volunteer who keeps messing up. How someone handles influence with “low-status” people predicts how they'll use it with everyone.
11. Notice who's already shepherding informally.
Some people already have a handful of others who call them when life falls apart. They're pastoring without permission. Your job is mostly to recognize that and equip them.
12. Get others involved in a strategic & systematic way.
You could turn several of these into a "leadership noticing" practice: ask staff and ministry leads to submit one name a month with a specific observed behavior, not just "she'd be great." Collecting those over time often reveals the same few names from different directions, and that pattern is usually worth following up on.
Becoming Sherpas for climbing Everest tracks similarly to finder leaders for people’s journey to connect at your church.
A 2018 report found the climbing industry in the Himalayas was suffering from a dangerous shortage of its most important resource: experienced Sherpa guides.
One operator blamed rivals who take only experienced Sherpas and wouldn't invest in the next generation. In one case, a young Sherpa who was meant to be carrying equipment ended up guiding before he'd summited Everest himself!
Your ability to identify connection leaders will be the ceiling of your church’s Connection Culture.
Leaders are spotted by trusting them with small loads first, through relationships where someone vouches for them, and by inviting the best learners back to teach.
The shortage of them can be costly, not just for connection ministry itself, but for guests and for you personally.
But the abundance of a bench of them? That’s the sweet spot.
Which one of these 12 signals for identifying leaders do you most resonate with? Why?
Which signal is the most practical to implement in your church’s ministry over the next 3 months?
Name the first 3 steps in implementing that strategy. Can you put them on your teams calendar in a well paced and strategic way?